Summary
- Strategy and Metaplanet risk MSCI index removal as proposed screening rules examine operating assets, cash flow, expenses, and capital dependence.
- Strategy could face approximately $2.8 billion in passive outflows, while MSCI requires multiple financial flags before determining company ineligibility.
- Existing constituents receive additional safeguards against temporary failures, while MSCI will gather market feedback before deciding whether to adopt its framework.
Strategy and Metaplanet risk losing their places in major MSCI indexes under proposed rules targeting companies with substantial non-operating assets.
MSCI is considering broader screening standards that examine whether corporate issuers maintain sufficient operating activities relative to their overall asset structures. Consequently, companies holding significant Bitcoin reserves could face scrutiny without MSCI introducing rules specifically for digital asset treasury businesses.
According to MSCI’s consultation, a simulation using May 2026 data identified Strategy and Metaplanet as companies that would face deletion. Uranium investment company Yellow Cake would also leave the MSCI ACWI IMI under the simulated methodology.
Moreover, SharpLink, Center Laboratories, and Lydia Holding would enter a public watchlist under the proposed framework. Their inclusion shows that MSCI’s screening extends beyond companies primarily associated with cryptocurrency holdings.
Strategy represents the largest company flagged for potential removal, with a free-float-adjusted market capitalization of approximately $23.9 billion.
An MSCI exit could carry considerable financial implications because passive funds allocate capital based on index membership. JPMorgan analysts previously estimated Strategy could experience approximately $2.8 billion in passive outflows if MSCI removes it.
Also Read: XRP Faces Final Drop to $0.93 as Major Bottom Signal Takes Shape
MSCI Screening Examines Corporate Asset Structures
MSCI proposes a two-stage process for determining whether companies qualify as operating businesses within its indexes. Initially, the provider would assess whether operating assets represent a sufficient portion of each company’s overall balance sheet.
Companies failing that assessment would face five additional measures covering operating assets, expenses, cash flow, fair value changes, and capital dependence. Operating assets below 20% of total assets would generate one exclusion flag under the proposal. Additionally, operating expenses below 5% of total assets would represent another negative indicator.
Negative operating cash flow would create another flag, while substantial non-operating fair value changes would also count against companies. Those fair value changes must exceed 5% of total assets to meet MSCI’s proposed threshold.
Meanwhile, capital dependence above 20% would represent the fifth measure within MSCI’s assessment. Companies must trigger four financial flags alongside failing the core screen to become ineligible.
Existing MSCI Members Get Additional Protection From Removal
However, MSCI would provide existing constituents with greater protection against removal caused by temporary financial changes. Current members must fail the screening across two consecutive annual filings before MSCI removes them.
This requirement aims to limit unnecessary index turnover while identifying persistent changes in corporate structures. Hence, a temporary threshold breach would not automatically jeopardize an existing company’s index membership.
For Strategy and Metaplanet, the proposal places their Bitcoin-heavy treasury structures within MSCI’s broader examination of non-operating assets. Both companies maintain substantial Bitcoin reserves alongside their respective underlying business operations.
Significantly, the proposal has not changed MSCI index compositions, meaning neither Strategy nor Metaplanet has received a confirmed removal decision. MSCI previously chose against immediately excluding digital asset treasury companies while developing its broader approach toward non-operating businesses.
Conclusion
MSCI is accepting market feedback through September 30 and expects to announce consultation results by October 16. Strategy and Metaplanet therefore face potential index exits only if MSCI ultimately adopts the proposed company screening framework.
Also Read: Bitcoin Struggles Near $63,000 as Weak US Demand Undercuts Inflation Boost
